Monday, November 16

Crest Coffee House serves community through faith, pay-what-you-can model

By Sarah Jackson

Staff Writer

Nine minutes away from Trevecca campus, “Hey Jude” by the Beatles plays softly as customers settle into brown leather couches or work quietly at tables, their laptops open beside cups of coffee. Plants and local artwork fill the warm, dimly lit space. On the walls, Scripture and Christ-inspired messages offer something else to take in between sips.

Prayer board on the wall at Crest Coffee House (Trevechoes/Sarah Jackson)

At Crest Coffee House in Nashville’s Wedgewood-Houston neighborhood, guests can order a latte without worrying about whether they can afford it.

Shell and Jerry discovered Crest while walking through the neighborhood on their way to a gallery. Looking for a coffee shop, they stepped into a space where a verse of the day and faith-inspired quotes hung on the walls.

“We found this place on our way to an art gallery. Honestly, if I didn’t live so far, I would come here every day to write. It’s really charming,” Shell said.

It is the kind of stop Crest hopes people will make, whether they are passing through, meeting friends or looking for somewhere to spend a few quiet hours. An extension of Hillcrest Community Church, the donation-based shop welcomes everyone, regardless of church affiliation or ability to pay.

But keeping that welcome available depends on customers coming through the door.

“But honestly, if we had more business, we’d keep our heads above water. We have generous customers,” said Dana Barnes, who manages the shop. “Our average daily donation is hardly ever below the suggested $6 per drink.”

The difficulty, she explained, is that some days are slow.

The concept began in 2018 with two Hillcrest worship leaders who wanted a place where God would be honored, community could grow, and finances would not stand between someone and a good cup of coffee.

Free bibles on a table located at Crest Coffee House (Trevechoes/Sarah Jackson)

That purpose shows up throughout the shop. Guests can leave requests on a prayer wall or share gratitude on a praise wall. Bibles are available for those who need one, and a small book nook invites visitors to take a book or leave one behind. Local student and community artwork adds color to the space, while plants are available for purchase.

There is room to gather around tables, settle onto a couch or sit on the back patio.

The menu offers familiar flavors under names drawn from Scripture and faith. Reckless Love combines white chocolate and raspberry, while the honey-and-cinnamon latte is called Promised Land. Psalm 34:8 blends hazelnut and caramel.

Seasonal offerings include Crème Brûlée, Pumpkin Pie and Banana Pancake lattes, along with Pumpkin Cloud Chai. Get it hot or iced.

For barista Paisley Bodager, a junior at Lipscomb University and an aspiring entrepreneur, the appeal extends beyond the drinks and décor.

“Big corporations say they care about their employees, but the boss here genuinely cares about her employees,” Bodager said.

She also enjoys her coworkers and describes the customers as fun and sweet. Of the places she has worked, Crest is her favorite.

Bodager found the position through Handshake, a platform that connects students with employment opportunities. Other baristas attend nearby universities, including Trevecca and Belmont. Barnes coordinates their schedules around student commitments and plans to hire for the semester beginning in January.

Mission statement for Crest Coffee House (Trevechoes/Sarah Jackson)

The baristas are the shop’s only paid employees. Others volunteer their time, and donations of supplies help cover expenses. According to Barnes, church board members pay for milk, while her family provides pastries, teas, barista supplies, and décor.

Barnes said the coffee shop has covered its expenses without church funding since its accounts were separated from the church’s about a year and a half ago, when she began managing it. Still, steady customer traffic matters.

Along with daily coffee service, Crest hosts study nights, worship nights and performances by local student songwriters.

“We would love to host more Bible study groups and live music,” Barnes said.

A study night is scheduled for Thursday, Nov. 12, from 6 to 9 p.m., giving students additional time to spread out their books and work.

For readers looking to support Crest, stopping in for a drink, bringing a friend or choosing it as a regular meeting place can help sustain the space. Those able to give more can help keep coffee accessible to someone who cannot.

The invitation begins with a cup of coffee. At Crest, the hope is that people find a reason to stay.

Visit Crest Coffee House: 1601 Martin St., Nashville, TN 37203. Regular hours are Monday–Saturday, 7 a.m.–3 p.m., and Sunday, 8–10 a.m. Learn more at https://www.nashvillehillcrest.com/crest-coffee-house.

Outside view of Crest Coffee House (Trevechoes/Sarah Jackson)

Discover more from TrevEchoes Online

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.